Are Some Businesses Impacted More by Online Reviews?

Published:
09
November 2017
Updated:
01
December 2025
Viewed: 1003 times
Rated: 5.0 / 2 votes
Rate
article

The days of relying solely on reviews in print publications are over. These days, many people turn to the Internet when they want to find out what others think about entertainment, dining, and other types of options. Even local trades professionals like plumbers and air conditioning experts are subject to review at one site or another.

The question is not whether online reviews do impact consumer decisions. They certainly do. What many wonder is if companies in specific industries are more likely to gain or suffer because of online consumer feedback. The answer is yes.

Why Online Reviews are So Effective

To understand the impact online reviews has on how consumers view different businesses, it's helpful to grasp why they work so well in the first place. Online reviews eliminate one of the inherent problems with more traditional methods. With word or mouth or even a review by someone who is considered an industry expert, the reader only gets one point of view. When the reader is able to look at multiple reviews online, it's easier to get a broader idea of how well a company satisfies clients.

Online reviews are considered more accessible and more permanent. They remain online for as long as the review site is intact. The consumer can go back and read them any time the need arises. Between the broader range of reviews and the fact they are always there, is it any wonder that consumers like them so much?

Savvy Consumers and Interpreting Reviews

Many consumers have become adept at spotting what are sometimes called planted reviews. These are usually written to make the business and the product line look more appealing. They may be short on details and long on superlatives.

Others are classed as joke reviews. They provide little in the way of detail and may provide a quick laugh at best. Those are also not helpful in terms of deciding whether the company or product is a good choice.

Savvy readers have learned that spotting objective reviews means considering the elements of the review proper. Is it relatively free of typos, hyperbole, and overly profuse marketing language? Has the reviewer used all capital letters to convey emotion rather than let the words do the talking? Does it give the reader a clear idea of what the reviewer specifically gained or lost by using the products? Answers to these questions help readers decide if a review is of any value or if it should be overlooked.

If ratings come along with the actual review, most consumers know to be on guard if the business has consistent scores of one out of five. The same holds true if all the reviews come with perfect scores. That tends to demonstrate somebody has an axe to grind or the reviews may be written by those who have a stake in making sure people buy the goods or services.

Why Business Owners Should Care

Legitimate reviews help your business reputation. The value of other kinds is questionable. What you hope to do is encourage actual customers to write reviews and be frank about their experiences. Feedback that is real tends to invite discussion, both on the review site and among your management team. It helps identify strong points and could point the way toward ideas that help improve your business model .

Legitimate reviews are free marketing for your products and your brand. Acknowledge the praise by thanking the reviewer. When the critique is less than glowing, it's also important to respond in a professional manner. In industries where the competition is stiff, ignoring a negative review that happens to be detailed and concise in the criticism is poison. Treat it as a chance to improve the way things are done. The company reputation is enhanced when other readers see the company refrains from attacking and instead is willing to learn from negative reviews.

You'll make a better impression on future readers if you:

  • Balance your response. Thank consumers for positive reviews and invite them to come back whenever they need something you offer.
  • Stay cool and collected when responding to a negative review. No matter how outrageous or inflammatory the review happens to be, avoid responding with insults or arguing. Provide an apology and some way for the consumer to contact the company directly. The goal is to show others your company takes negative experiences seriously and genuinely wants to resolve whatever issue occurred.

So Which Industries are Impacted Most?

There are indications that some industries are impacted to a greater degree by online reviews. Hospitality is a good example. This industry tends to include hotels, motels, eateries of all types, and some venues like bars.

You will find marketing reports that indicate the hospitality industry is more impacted by online reviews than any other single group. As many as 60% of consumers will look for restaurant reviews before they try a place for the first time. If the rating is below four stars, many of those consumers won't bother to read the reviews. Around 40% read the reviews before booking a reservation at a hotel and also tend to stay away when most of the reviews are less than three stars.

Healthcare and tradespeople like plumbers, electricians, and home contractors also come in for their fair share of scrutiny. Parents review pediatricians at a rate of 30% before taking their kids for treatment. Over half of adults will check out general practitioner reviews before they settle on a new family doctor. Plumbers and other tradespeople can rest assured that over half of their prospective customers read online reviews before giving them a call.

Whether you are operating a multi-national company or own a local business, take those online reviews seriously. Pay attention to all the legitimate reviews, including the ones that offer less than glowing comments. There is much you can learn from a negative review that is constructive and provides details about what happened. The way you respond to all legitimate reviews will either help you defuse an unfortunate situation or allow it to stand as a testament that you don't care much about what the customers think.

Online Reviews Impact on Businesses FAQs

How can a business set up a sustainable review-generation system?

Create a simple, automatic flow tied to real touchpoints: post-purchase emails, SMS after service completion, and QR codes at checkout. Ask with neutral language (“How was your experience?”) and route unhappy customers to a private form while happy customers get links to public platforms. Track request → review conversion so you know which channel produces the most credible feedback.

Which platforms should I prioritize for reviews and why?

Prioritize where your customers actually search: Google for local intent, industry sites (e.g., Healthgrades, G2, Tripadvisor) for niche decisions, and Facebook for community proof. Each platform has different moderation rules and visibility; one strong profile beats five weak ones. Start with one primary, one secondary, and only expand once you can keep response times and quality high.

When is the best time to ask for a review?

Ask at the “peak of delight,” right after a successful resolution or delivery, when details are vivid and motivation is high. For services with delayed outcomes (repairs, healthcare follow-ups), schedule a polite nudge a few days later to capture results. Avoid stacking requests (email + SMS + call) on the same day; spaced reminders convert better and feel less pushy.

How do I deal with obviously fake or malicious reviews?

Document everything — screenshots, timestamps, and any mismatch with customer records — then use the platform’s dispute process with concise evidence. Publish a calm, public reply stating you can’t locate the transaction and inviting the reviewer to contact you offline. This signals transparency to real prospects while you work the removal behind the scenes.

Can reviews influence my visibility in local search packs?

Yes, freshness, volume, star rating, and review text that mentions relevant services can correlate with better local prominence. Encourage customers to describe what they bought or what problem you solved in natural language (never script it). Pair reviews with complete profiles (categories, photos, hours) to strengthen overall local relevance.

Should I use reviews in ads and on landing pages?

Absolutely — social proof reduces friction and increases conversion, especially near CTAs and pricing. Match testimonial content to the page’s promise (speed, quality, price, convenience) and include a photo, name, or company for credibility. Rotate snippets to avoid “ad fatigue,” and A/B test placements (above fold vs. near form) to quantify lift.

What’s an ethical way to increase positive reviews without incentives?

Improve moments that matter: faster replies, clear expectations, and proactive issue resolution. Close the loop — after fixing a problem, politely ask if the customer is willing to update or add a review about the resolution. Train staff to recognize “thank you” moments and respond with, “I’m glad we could help — would you mind sharing that experience online?”

How can I turn review feedback into operational improvements?

Tag reviews by theme (wait time, staff, price, product quality) and review monthly trends with the frontline team. Choose one “fix of the month,” implement it, and watch for corresponding shifts in the tagged themes. Publicly acknowledge improvements in your responses (“We’ve extended weekend hours based on feedback”) to show customers their voice matters.

What’s a smart response framework for mixed or negative reviews?

Use A.C.T.: Acknowledge the specific issue, Clarify next steps or context without being defensive, and Transform the experience with a concrete offer or fix. Keep replies human and concise, moving sensitive details to a private channel quickly. Follow up publicly once resolved so future readers see the outcome.

How do I measure the business impact of reviews beyond star ratings?

Track assisted conversions: clicks from review profiles to your site, call tracking numbers unique to profiles, and coupon codes used by review readers. Monitor review velocity (new reviews per month) and response time as leading indicators of pipeline health. Correlate changes in these metrics with booking rates or revenue to justify continuing investment in reputation management.

Mike Zhmudikov

Written by Mike Zhmudikov SEO Director

Mike’s influence is deeply embedded in the success narratives of our projects. His ability to foresee market trends, coupled with his adeptness at blending technical SEO knowledge with managerial acumen has culminated in a track record of measurable outcomes and satisfied Clientele.

Bio